The Whitney Biennial 2026 catalog reviewed

As I say most every time I review the Biennial, I write that the catalog is important because it is what endures, and can define an exhibition long after the show has closed and/or been forgotten – sometimes the book defines matters better than the art in the galleries does. History (to quote myself again) is not written by the victors, but by the survivors. So what does the 2026 Biennial catalog say about the show?

First, a reminder that I was underwhelmed by the exhibit. It felt formless and arbitrary, and in these days when meaning carries extra weight, that was a disappointment. I won’t say it was bad, but it ought to have been much more. The cover of the catalog breaks the word Biennial in half, giving us “Bien” – French for “good” – at the top. This captures my ambivalence nicely; I found the show good when it ought to have been more.

2026 marks twenty years since I started attending Whitney Biennials regularly, and I buy the catalog every time I go. The anniversary is nicely bookended by the thickness of the catalogs; 2006 and 2026 being similar in format and density. The 2006 book is thick because it contains multiple foldouts of works exclusive to the catalog; in 2026 the space is taken up with conversations between the artists and a friend or colleague or family member, or all of them at once. This conversational approach has risks, but these are avoided, and for the most part they add to our understanding of each artist’s point of view and their intent regarding specific works.

My collection of Biennial catalogs.

The initial essays, by Biennial curators Marcela Guerrero and Drew Sawyer, take opposite approaches to the daunting if not impossible task of defining this exhibition. Guerrero speaks in theory, dangerously close to jargon, spending time on the phrase “gestational relationality”, to explain one of the ideas contained within the show. It doesn’t help. Sawyer’s more straightforward approach deals with the process of curating a show with such a broad and formless history. What does a Biennial seek to define? Is such a definition even possible in the fragmented archipelagoes of today’s art world?

What becomes clear, and is occasionally stated explicitly in the book, is how the concept of “American” is without a clear definition. Artists from Palestine, Afghanistan, Native American tribes, Hawaii, are simultaneously aware of their outsider status, yet they are inside as well – there is no question that they belong in an American art museum. Like art itself, identity is flexible and evolves continually. At times, even when the art did not excite me, the artist’s engagement with their ideas and work did. I enjoyed the book a lot more than I enjoyed the show itself.

I was distressed to see some artists speak positively about AI, but relieved that there were so few of them, and others had better ideas. Even the catalog’s low points have some value: Charles Ray and Isabelle Francis McGuire have an interesting conversation, but it has little to do with her work.

It wouldn’t be a review if I failed to quibble here and there. A little judicious editing might have helped, especially when the book is 500 pages long. Director Scott Rothkopf‘s introduction is really only four paragraphs long: after that he throws in a few paragraphs of standard museum boilerplate about the staff, and then some acknowledgements that should have gone into the Acknowledgments section that follows.

It would have been easy to create a dystopian Biennial to match the crumbling Empire around us, but Guerrero and Sawyer found moments of beauty and optimism even in these dark days. I found myself nodding and giving an emphatic “Yeah!” to artist Samia Halaby‘s quote below, which perfectly ends her conversation with Hannah Priscilla Craig, Director of Culture and Communication at the People’s Forum.

Quote by Samia Halaby, on page 237 of the catalog.

Text

The Whitney Biennial 2026 reviewed

I always bring back something. Photo from the Whitney

This year’s Whitney Biennial has closed (though portions will remain on view as late as October), so this is less of a review and more of a post-mortem. That’s an exaggeration, but not much of one. I always find something to enjoy at a Biennial, also things that annoy, and (worst) those which inspire no reaction whatsoever. Artists wince when someone walks into a gallery and barely slows as nothing catches their eye.

This is an exhibit without a central theme; theme being one of the major challenges to any Biennial curator. The occasional (Okay, repeated) bafflement of viewers continues as it always had, as abstract digital animation gives way to fairly ordinary painted portraits; it wouldn’t be a Biennial without a “Huh?” moment or two. I enjoy working a Biennial out, as though it were a puzzle. Sometimes, I avoid wall labels to make that feeling last, While there are some themes mildly explored, none is overarching. The 2026 Biennial is untitled, for what word could sum up such a miscellany without sounding self-critical?

This might be a bit hyperbolic. I didn’t dislike the show, I just couldn’t raise much enjoyment from it either. Like so much of this Trump 2.0 world, a bit of exhaustion has set in, and organization in many senses seems like too much work. Intent on making the best of things, how about I give you highlights?

SHE MUST BE A MATRIARCH by Anna Tsouhlarakis, 2023; my photo

Every Biennial needs a large sculptural work to catch the eye from a distance, and this Biennial has several, from Young Joon Kwak‘s Divine Dance of Soft Revolt (Anna, Travis, Me), 2024, to Anna Tsouhlarakis‘s surreal take on an equestrian monument, She Must Be A Matriarch, 2023 (above). Throw in Pat Oleszko‘s Blowhard, 1995, (below) which looks like a refugee from Yellow Submarine, and sculpture might be the best represented discipline.

Pat Oleszko, Blowhard, 1995 (left)

Interesting that the most eye-catching pieces in the show are both older; Blowhard, shown above, from 1995, and the paintings of Carmen de Monteflores, below, from the late 1960s. De Monteflores is a delight, still vibrant and vital so many decades later. The muted sculptures by her daughter, Andrea Fraser, complement the paintings without challenging them. Their pairing, which could easily have seemed gimmicky, was a delight. I’m sorry to say de Monteflores stopped painting in 1970, but happy to know she is still with us.

Two paintings by Carmen de Monteflores, with sculptures by her daughter, Andrea Fraser

Installation was scant, the best being Zach Blas‘s, CULTUS, 2023, a kitschy, 80s-inflected ritual chamber for summoning an AI god, a horrible concept (which some take seriously) given the heavy metal treatment via dark walls and LED lights. All you need is a cameo by Bruce Campbell and you’d have a horror film.

Malcolm Peacock, Five of them were hers and she carved shelters with windows into the backs of their skulls, 2024 (detail). My photo.

Malcolm Peacock’s Five of them were hers and she carved shelters with windows into the backs of their skulls, 2024 (above) had a fabulous texture, as it is covered in synthetic hair, adding extra interest to the always-interesting bark of a tree trunk. Tactile qualities made this year’s sculptures particularly appealing – but don’t touch.

Michelle Lopez, Pandemonium, 2025

I wandered into Michelle Lopez‘s Pandemonium, 2025, at the wrong time. A gallery where people looked up at a circular screen overhead…okay…It shows a blue sky with trash blowing in the wind. Maybe it’s not trash – certainly the American flag that appears seems clean and whole. It seems kind of…dull. Then I saw it from the beginning, which blew up my initial impression. The debris fluttering over the screen when I walked in was the aftermath of a disaster, the silence after the screams.

My girlfriend and I attended the Whitney’s Free Friday Nights, which is a godsend for those of us who can only visit NYC, and then only on a tight budget. The evening was humid and the lowering clouds turned to rain while we were inside. People looked out at the rain and a few flashes of lightning. The art had to twiddle its thumbs and wait; Mother Nature had upstaged them.

Next time, as always, I will review the exhibition catalog.

The Odds on The Odyssey

A pre-release poster for The Odyssey (2026)

I confess I hadn’t seen a film in IMAX before I went to see Christopher Nolan‘s The Odyssey last Friday, and I don’t know how long it will be before I see another. I don’t blame IMAX or the film, but the combination of Nolan’s intense filmmaking and IMAX’s seat-shaking audio/visual assault left me drained. My girlfriend and I had to take a minute in the lobby afterward to recover.

What’s ancient Greek for “Darth Vader”? Agamemnon in The Odyssey

Nolan has unwisely presented us with a video-game version of the story, featuring every battle and struggle, but little of the humanity and none of the humor of the original. Even the tagline in the poster above misleads, as there is less defying Gods than you might expect from this story – indeed, the whole subplot about Helen of Troy, her ancestry, her marriage to Paris of Troy and so on is absent – a shame, since (despite the foaming at the mouth of right-wing media) Lupita Nyong’o is a stunningly lovely woman, and more than talented enough for the part.

In fact, Nolan is well served by his actors throughout. When a character is underdeveloped, it is always the script – I’m thinking particularly of Charlize Theron as Calypso, who, like Helen, deserves deeper exploration. Because of the lack of humor, Matt Damon as Odysseus has to suffer throughout without a moment’s rest, leaving him in a glum funk that dampens his scenes, even at the end, as he reunited (spoilers) with his wife, Penelope (Anne Hathaway) and son, Telemachus (Tom Holland). From time to time Zendaya appears, as the goddess Athena, but she is allowed little to do – another shame.

Zendaya as Athena in The Odyssey

By the way, I love the fan theory that, since Paul Atreides, the hero of Dune and some of its sequels, is supposedly descended from the house of Atreus, The Odyssey may be considered a Dune prequel. A shame they haven’t (yet) found a way to link Athena and Chani, since Zendaya plays them both, in not dissimilar garb.

Now that I have damned, my praise should not be faint. Nolan knows how to pack an action sequence until you can feel the struggle of every challenge. The special effects are excellent, and never broke the illusion. I think Nolan was particularly wise to refrain from putting in the Sirens’s song, as it was unlikely anything could come close to how it sounds in our imagination. He keeps the camera at a distance, refusing to throw in a bit of gratuitous nudity – at least, I think they were nude. From that far away, who can tell?

To truly capture the scope of Homer‘s epic, you need more than a single film; even a trilogy might strain to capture all of it. The fact that Nolan succeeded in bits and pieces is still a considerable achievement. I can only hope some day he chooses to let the story dictate the length. Suppose someone were to take The Lord of the Rings and made a single film of it – one battle after another, no time for jokes (adieu, Merry and Pippin) and barely a chance to catch your breath. Movies are not the best storytelling medium – go and read The Odyssey if you haven’t – but at their best they can pack a wallop. I’m not especially eager to see The Odyssey again, unlike some of Nolan’s other films, but I’m glad I saw it.

Amid the Ruins

This post could be challenging for you; I know it is for me. In this post (and, by the way, do you hate essays that begin by telling you what the writer is going to say, like it was a thesis paper for school? I do.) I’m going to write about something I cannot explain, and another thing I will not explain. Like modern jazz, you just have to roll with it.

A still from Angel’s Egg (1985), showing the titular egg and the two characters.

I recently watched Angel’s Egg (1985), the cryptic – to say the least – film directed by Mamoru Oshii, and designed by artist Yoshitaka Amano. It’s a fascinating film because of its near-total lack of context or explanation. In a city, perhaps deserted, seemingly ruined, a young man, possibly a soldier, meets a little girl, who is hiding a large egg in her dress. They speak little, and do not answer each other’s questions. He carries a weapon that resembles a cross; she is barefoot, and her dress is too large for her.

Another still.

Other figures appear, troops who throw spears or harpoons at the shadows of huge fish, to no effect. But where are the fish? And why are these men hunting them? Large machines, perhaps troop carriers or other engines of war, appear. And the ultimate fate of the egg and what’s inside it remains unclear.

The slow pace, dreamlike imagery, and complete absence of any explanation takes the film to a different level. Perhaps a coherent storyline, or some sort of narrator, would only diminish the unworldly aspects of the story. There are hints of Christian symbolism, which teeter close to explanation when the young man recounts some of the story of the Flood. The viewer does not so much see the film end as awaken from it, interrupted as dreams are by the everyday world. No answers are given, but the film is not there to present answers. The journey is the point, even if they end up in the same ruins in which they began.

The cover of The Slow Regard of Silent Things

What came to mind after I watched Angel’s Egg was a novella by Patrick Rothfuss, The Slow Regard of Silent Things (2014), a companion to his Kingkiller Chronicle novels. The Slow Regard of Silent Things is a digression involving Auri, a young woman who plays a small part in the novels, and the abandoned ruins she lives in. It is written from her point of view, and shows much about her state of mind as she goes about her unusual daily activities. I’m being deliberately cryptic. The best thing I can do is leave you in the dark, so you may discover this marvelous story directly. The writing is fine, much as the artwork in Angel’s Egg is. The difference is we learn about Auri, her life, and (in the novels) some context that explains who she is and why she is living that way. Her surroundings and their ruined state are not explained, and I could almost imagine Auri as the little girl from Angel’s Egg grown up.

I’m not suggesting any actual connection between the two; I am unaware if Patrick Rothfuss has ever seen Angel’s Egg, or what he does (or would) think of it. It’s just the affinity between the little girl living on her own (it seems), cherishing her treasured egg, and a young woman living on her own with her own treasures. Kvothe, the main character of the Kingkiller Chronicle stories, has some affinities with the young man in Angel’s Egg – again, that’s just my imagination roaming free.

Patrick Rothfuss has made it clear that The Slow Regard of Silent Things should be read in context, and would make a poor introduction to the series. I ignored him, and read it first, which provided a little extra dreamlike quality to the story. Angel’s Egg also feels like a side-story in some much larger and more elaborate tale, though none exists. I liked the movie very much, and I loved the book. Seek them out; you might be confused, but you won’t be disappointed.

Prose about verse

The subject(s) of this post

I envy poets. They work with language like skilled musicians – for poetry is music, and vice versa – abstractly or realistically as they choose. I have always found writing poetry difficult, though I continue to try now and then, hopeful of some inspiration or breakthrough. Reading poetry has also challenged me; much rhyming poetry reminds me of Dr. Seuss, who I adore, but do not find him appropriate to all occasions. Modern poetry, which eschews rhyme and rigid meter is more my style.

The connections between poetry and visual art helped me find my way into reading poems regularly. Art critics like the late Peter Schjeldahl wrote poems on the side, while poets like John Ashbery wrote art criticism as their day job. Of the latter group it was Frank O’Hara who helped me find my way into poetry, for it was his book Lunch Poems, published by City Lights , the booktore and publisher of San Francisco, that introduced me to the City Lights Pocket Poets Series. Exploring that series has made me a poetry lover. Herein follows capsule reviews of the books shown above, all of which I have enjoyed.

O’Hara’s Lunch Poems (1964), written around or during lunchtime, have a fine casualness and wit that made for a welcome introduction to the series, which began in the 1950s and continues to this day. His range flows from the solemnly artistic (“Image of the Buddha preaching”) to the opposite (“Mary Desti’s Ass”). I bought the book because of O’Hara’s friendship with artists, and I was hooked.

Allen Ginsberg‘s most famous and notorious work, Howl (1956), was my second purchase, one of several books Ginsberg published in the Pocket Poets Series. Has there been a more quoted opening line in modern poetry than “I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness, starving hysterical naked…”? The comparative tameness of some of the other poems in the book only highlight how revolutionary Howl was – and is.

It was through Rebecca Solnit praising Diane di Prima‘s writing in Solnit’s memoir, Recollections of My Nonexistence (2021), that led me to seek out di Prima’s Revolutionary Letters (1971 – expanded 50th anniversary edition 2021). This book is so timely now, as we seem to be reliving much of the 1960s, that large parts of it feels as though they were written today. From the hippie origins of the book, detailing what you would need should The Man come for you, or observations about war, whether it is in Vietnam or the Persian Gulf, her trenchant wit and liberal outrage feel utterly contemporary. Her observation in Letter #75, subtitled “Rant,” clarified a lot of my feelings about today’s world: “The only war that matters is the war against the imagination.” And the prayer her children taught her, from Letter #98, “Things Too Ridiculous to Put Up With,” has also become a favorite: “God, God, Don’t make Everything Ridiculous.”

The same poem, sort of.

Looking over the series in a more organized fashion, I discovered that Pablo Picasso was included, in a 1968 book entitled “Hunk of Skin,” likely the least pleasant title, but hey. It has been out of print for a while, so I had to search for a good copy. It presents the poems in their original Spanish, paired with English translations by Paul Blackburn. I cannot comment on the translations as translations, for my Spanish is rudimentary at best, but I have questions about Blackburn’s changing the line breaks, at least once in mid-word, and how that affects the work as a whole. The image above does not even show the entire English version – Blackburn’s changes force it to spread onto the following page. As a poet, Picasso was a brilliant artist, so expectations should be held in check. However, Picasso’s observations have a certain artistry of their own, and I enjoy owning a book published during his lifetime.

Finally, the most recent of the Pocket Poets Series, Will Alexander‘s Divine Blue Light (for John Coltrane) (2022), which I just finished reading yesterday. It’s a pleasure to report that City Lights continues to produce fine books, and does not fall into repetition or habit. Alexander’s poems remind me of John Coltrane in the way both men start off familiarly, only to turn quickly into abstraction and allow their expression to flow free. Just when you think you understand what Alexander is saying, he begins using words in unexpected ways, often with phrase after phrase of comparison (“…its hemispheres colliding / as bricolage / as osmosis / as sonic notation…” from the title poem) until meaning is abandoned in waves of sound. My advice: when his poems do this, let the music carry you, as a Coltrane cover of a standard winds up far from anything resembling the original song.

Perhaps in time I’ll cover some more, but for now I’m happily basking in the words, their meanings, and sometimes their lack of meaning. Who knows: perhaps one day I’ll be able to write poetry myself. If so, these books helped lead me there.

In the Moment

I’ve been away from blogging for a while, so to restart things, here’s a poem I wrote today:

In the Moment

“And then,” she said,
without preamble
without context,
continuing a conversation
with someone
with something
that had been rudely interrupted;
a game of telephone
with reality.

No life exists on its own.
Warp and weft reach back
to the big bang
and forward to the big crunch
while we,
with our junk food and beverages
try to figure out
just where we are
in this unending, unfathomable tale.

Every saga is begun
in the middle:
the exposition, backstory,
appendices and endnotes
rushing to fill in
every take-a-breath lacuna
and pregnant pause

Meaning, meanwhile,
cools its heels
and reads a magazine
three years out of date
and stares at the beige carpet
in the beige waiting room,
for the world to start turning again

Charles Chaplin’s The Freak reviewed

The front cover, showing Victoria Chaplin wearing a set of wings made for the film

Do we all dream of flying? Is this some sort of shared vision since the first protohumans saw their first bird? Certainly fantasies have long dealt with people who could (or learned to) fly. Think of Peter Pan, or Arthur Dent in So Long And Thanks for all the Fish, the fourth of the Hitch-Hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy books (As the Guide itself says of flying, “The knack lies in learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss.”). There is the titular character of Mervyn Peake’s 1953 novel Mr. Pye, who grows wings as he commits good deeds, and tried to shed them by doing bad ones. Or you could consider Pygar, the blind angel in the Barbarella comics and film. I could run on like this for quite a while, but I won’t.

Jane Fonda as Barbarella and John Philip Law as Pygar in Barbarella (1968)

Charles Chaplin’s The Freak: The Story of an Unfinished Film, by David Robinson (Sticking Place Books, 2025), gives us an thorough yet tantalizing peek into Chaplin‘s final project, of which no footage was shot, through the script as it stood at Chaplin’s death, to production art and more.

Following the decidedly mixed (i.e. negative) response to his 1967 film, A Countess from Hong Kong, Chaplin looked to a more fantastic story. A winged girl named Sarapha is found in South America. Her parents were English missionaries; after their deaths the girl lived alone, her wings a source of fear and wonderment among the locals. Once she is brought back to England, the same responses arise in the supposedly more civilized English. People wish to exploit her for commercial or religious purposes (“We’ll print our own bible!” says one character [p.88]). In the end…ah, but I won’t give away the ending.

It’s difficult to say just how finished the script is. Certainly there was considerable preproduction work, and several times production itself seemed close at hand, but, after a series of strokes, Chaplin’s family concluded that he was no longer up to the challenge, and quietly shut down production without telling him. Chaplin would continue to work on the script, and said repeatedly in interviews that it would be made. He died in 1977, 8 years after preproduction ceased, at age 88.

What would the film have been like? It has potential but, in my view, the film never quite gels. The dialog occasionally suffers from the pontifical qualities of Chaplin’s talkies, especially Limelight (1952), which aspires to profundity but rarely achieves it. The story could easily be taken into a more farcical direction, or a more mystical one, but it remains flat-footed. Too many characters, upon seeing Sarapha for the first time, faint. The revivalist preacher, Rev. James Gidson, seems to cry out for a broad, televangelist type, but he never quite crosses that line. Sarapha herself is somewhat passive, buffeted by all the unwelcome attention. Chaplin had high hopes for his daughter, Victoria, who was to play Sarapha; perhaps she would have provided the third dimension needed to bring the character to life – he certainly though so.

Brian Blessed as Vultan (center) in Flash Gordon (1980)

The book is well documented, and the production art gives us glimpses of what might have been. There are also photos of Victoria wearing the wings; they look pretty credible, certainly more than Pygar’s or the Hawkmen’s wings in Flash Gordon (1980).

Closing titles to The itch (1965)

I’ll drop one more: a 1965 cartoon from Paramount called The Itch, directed by Howard Post. It tells of a mild Englishman who unexplainedly grows wings. He gets to test them out, and causes a little fuss before they are accidentally shot off – but will they grow back? It’s a lightweight little short, with a bit more character and a better story than much of Paramount’s output in this period.

Of course, a lost Chaplin film is a great loss. His talkies are a fascinating mix of faint echoes from the past, and a future not quite fully formed. Reading The Freak, it’s easy to tell this is Chaplin’s own writing. It would have made a fascinating change from his previous films. As it is, we must content ourselves with it being a fascinating book.

Frankenstein reviewed

Oscar Isaac as Victor Frankenstein in Frankenstein, directed by Guillermo del Toro (2025)

(note: contains spoilers)

I missed seeing Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein (2025) in the theater (I think it was shown on 3 screens, 2 of which were above the Arctic Circle) so I saw it on Netflix the day it became available, November 7 – perhaps coincidentally the anniversary of the death of Dwight Frye, who was in the 1931 classic version. I was hopeful, as del Toro has been a horror fan for ages and has long dreamt of adapting Frankenstein. Now I can say that he has made a film to be proud of – perhaps not the icon the 1931 film is, but a worthy film, lush, beautiful, and riveting.

Boris Karloff as the Monster in Frankenstein (1931)


Adapting a classic work, especially when other versions have taken liberties both big and small, is not always easy. Besides the 1931 Boris Karloff classic already mentioned, del Toro has the Hammer Frankenstein films of the 1950s and 60s in mind, and Bernie Wrightson’s art for the 1983 edition of Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley’s book, published by Marvel Comics. (I haven’t seen any reference to Lynd Ward’s illustrations for the 1934 edition, published by Harrison Smith & Robert Haas – my personal favorite – but I’m sure they were studied.)

Charles Ogle as the Monster in Thomas Edison’s Frankenstein (1910)


It is from the start a del Toro film, and that means richness abounds. The sets, the costumes, and the scenes have a theatrical extravagance that holds the eye. Victor Frankenstein (Oscar Isaac) does his grisly work in a towering wreck of a building he must have rented from Saruman, and reminded me of the great house in del Toro’s Crimson Peak (2015). Mia Goth, who plays Elizabeth, is wrapped in sumptuous fabrics; Charles Dance, as Victor’s steely father, is swathed in black like some vampire elder, which Dance played in Dracula Untold (2014). Even the tattered clothes the Creature wears have a rich texture you can almost feel.

Illustration by Lynd Ward for the 1934 edition of Frankenstein (1818) by Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley


Wisely, del Toro does not try to challenge the dominance of Jack Pierce’s makeup for Boris Karloff’s monster, but instead clings closer to Mary Shelley’s description: a body assembled from various corpses, criss-crossed with scars, and of a sepulchral pallor. Jacob Elordi, as the Creature, is no nightmare to look at; at times he is almost handsome. His monstrousness comes through his huge size and strength, and through the depths of his pain, brought on by his mistreatment at Victor’s hands.

Illustration by Bernie Wrightson for Marvel Comics edition of Frankenstein (1983)


The formal, slightly stilted dialogue is faithful to the book. The cast put these speeches across without effort. Oscar Isaac carries a lot of emotional weight as Victor Frankenstein, and does so with ease. I idly wondered what he would be like as Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. I also wondered why Willem Dafoe was not in this film, but perhaps, after Poor Things (3000) and Nosferatu (4000) he needed a break from horror. Mia Goth is adequate, but I wished for more from her doll-like face and her limited involvement in the story. Her scenes with the Creature, like those of the blind man, give emotional weight that echo del Toro’s The Shape of Water (6000). David Bradley, as the blind old man who is the Creature’s friend, does very well in a role that offers no opening for physicality.

Mia Goth as Elizabeth and Jacob Elordi as the Creature in Frankenstein (2025)


Where del Toro has decided to expand on Shelley’s story is where he stumbles. His decision to make it a father/son tale, and to connect the Creature and its creator to Victor’s own unhappy childhood, slows the film down and complicates matters needlessly. It’s not a bad digression, but adds little. Giving Victor a brother, William, is also unnecessary; it muddles the love story by making Elizabeth William’s fiancee, adding extra emotional entanglement which might be better used elsewhere. In the course of the story Victor loses a leg – a nod to Captain Ahab, perhaps, or just a recurrence of the body horror del Toro already explored in The Shape of Water (2017), something I could have done without in both films.
In many ways, though, del Toro has been more faithful to Mary Shelley than most adaptors. The book has no sense of humor, though in this version Alexandre Desplat’s score stepped up once: in a sequence where Victor is cutting up bodies and assembling the Creature, Desplat provides an almost jaunty waltz, incongruous but a nice counteragent to the gore. A teasing scene involving Elizabeth going to confession, with Victor pursuing (stalking?) her also lightens the mood. The worst line in the film – “Victor, you are the monster.” – elicits groans the way a bad joke does; you hate it, but to lose it might make things worse.
The big set piece, the creation of the Creature, works pretty well. Mary Shelley wisely makes little mention of how this is accomplished, which gives filmmakers a wide-open field in which to play. In Thomas Edison’s 1910 version, the Creature is born in a cauldron, burning in reverse until it is whole – the highlight of the film. The Karloff classic became a template for years to come, with Kenneth Strickfaden’s electrical machines the perfect set dressing. Del Toro nods to this, but has the creature chained up on a cross, crucifixion turned into creation.

Jacob Elordi as the Creature, about to be brought to life.


All this sounds like damning with faint praise, but I enjoyed the film very much, and intend to rewatch it. It is not merely a monster movie, though it is that, but a story of the pain of growth, and how emotional scars do not heal the way physical scars do. It is, in a way, an anti-love story, teaching us how the lack of love warps lives and creates monsters. It begins and ends in the icy bleakness of the Arctic, and the bleakness of the pain shown in-between echoes the emotion. The monster cannot die, but perhaps, if he could only find the right people, he might be able to live.

Liberty takes work

The work in question. The paper is slightly green, which my phone’s camera did not capture.

I attended the No Kings rally on October 18, 2025, the second such rally I had been to. The crowd – largely white, mostly older – milled about, listened to music and speeches, and stood on the sidewalk and waved to passing cars. My corner of Massachusetts is fairly liberal, so there was very little pushback.

As I walked onto the town common to join the rally, I saw a portfolio propped against a tree, with a sign saying “Free Stuff.” Inside were copies of two prints: the one shown above, and another of a crown with birds flying out of it. I took one. There is no signature or other identification, so I cannot tell you anything about the artist. It was a juggling act carrying it with me, as I had my “Impeach” sign, which I made in 2019 when Donald Trump’s fate hung in the balance. Now, with the stakes far greater, I brought out my somewhat battered sign and put it back into use. The Statue of Liberty print is good size – the paper measures 18 x 24 inches – and my homemade sign is even larger, but neither felt burdensome, not when so much was at stake.

My handmade sign; an old photo, judging from the Christmas present in the upper right corner.

It’s been a long while since I wrote a post. My mind has been elsewhere, yet everything feels deeply personal. The future of the country is my future, and not to protest, not to stand up for what is right, would have felt like a betrayal. Somewhere in all this, an artist made this print and just left it for whoever came along. No thought of ego or fame, no nods to posterity. Whoever that was, I thank them. Keep fighting. Keep making art. I love this piece.

Moby Dick – Rehearsed

Orson Welles as Father Mapple in Moby Dick (1956)

The mid-1950s brought Orson Welles into repeated contact with Herman Melville‘s classic novel, Moby-Dick (published in 1851). In 1954 he went before movie cameras to play Father Mapple, who delivers a sermon to sailors about to set out to sea, for director John Huston. Reportedly, Welles wrote his own lines, though either he or credited screenwriter Ray Bradbury drew right from Melville anyway. But this turned out to be dipping a toe in the water, for Welles was intent on bringing the story to life in his own way, onstage. So, in 1955, while the movie was being completed (it would premiere in 1956), Welles mounted his own, mostly verse-based version of the story, which came to be called Moby Dick – Rehearsed.

Patrick McGoohan and Orson Welles in Moby Dick – Rehearsed

The conceit of the play is that a group of actors has assembled to rehearse King Lear, but the Actor Manager has changed his mind, and sets them to enacting Moby Dick instead. This is a thin framework, which allows the play to be staged with minimal props and sets, and with the actors in street clothes. Lighting, sound effects and music provide what atmosphere is not in the words. In these days of metafiction and deconstruction, I might have expected much more rehearsal and less straightforward dramatization, but that’s my assumptions getting in the way; Welles does a good job with the characters, and his blank verse reads well. It is only a two-act play, and so the smaller roles remain shadowy, but Captain Ahab and his first mate, Mr. Starbuck, get plenty of moments in the spotlight.

Orson Welles and Joan Plowright (AP Photo)

Welles staged the play in London, with a cast that is startling for the array of names who would go on to greater fame: Patrick McGoohan as Mr. Starbuck, Gordon Jackson (best remembered as Mr. Hudson in the British soap, Upstairs Downstairs), Peter Sallis (the voice of Wallace in the Wallace & Gromit films), Joan Plowright, Kenneth Williams, and others.

The play in book form, published by Samuel French

Welles had the idea to film the play at the end of its run, and sell the film to television; he started work on it, but left it incomplete when he felt it wasn’t working. For filming, Peter Sallis was replaced by Christopher Lee. It is not clear if any of the footage survives.

The play was successful enough that an American production was mounted, without Welles’s involvement, starring Rod Steiger as Ahab, and has been revived multiple times since. Between Melville and Welles, there is mystique aplenty around the play, and it will likely be revisited many times to come. I enjoyed it for what it is: a straightforward adaptation that seeks to keep some of the majesty of Melville’s writing intact, without letting it sprawl overmuch. Moby-Dick covers so much space in its action and its philosophical pondering that it could be turned into a massive play, such as David Edgar‘s 8 1/2 hour-long adaptation of Charles Dickens‘s Nicholas Nickleby, from 1980. I have no doubt more adaptations, faithful or modernist, will be forthcoming, but this one is worth seeking out. As shown, it is available in book form; some snippets of the play in performance are viewable online. Regardless, it’s a good read, and I hope to see it performed one day.