
As I say most every time I review the Biennial, I write that the catalog is important because it is what endures, and can define an exhibition long after the show has closed and/or been forgotten – sometimes the book defines matters better than the art in the galleries does. History (to quote myself again) is not written by the victors, but by the survivors. So what does the 2026 Biennial catalog say about the show?
First, a reminder that I was underwhelmed by the exhibit. It felt formless and arbitrary, and in these days when meaning carries extra weight, that was a disappointment. I won’t say it was bad, but it ought to have been much more. The cover of the catalog breaks the word Biennial in half, giving us “Bien” – French for “good” – at the top. This captures my ambivalence nicely; I found the show good when it ought to have been more.
2026 marks twenty years since I started attending Whitney Biennials regularly, and I buy the catalog every time I go. The anniversary is nicely bookended by the thickness of the catalogs; 2006 and 2026 being similar in format and density. The 2006 book is thick because it contains multiple foldouts of works exclusive to the catalog; in 2026 the space is taken up with conversations between the artists and a friend or colleague or family member, or all of them at once. This conversational approach has risks, but these are avoided, and for the most part they add to our understanding of each artist’s point of view and their intent regarding specific works.

The initial essays, by Biennial curators Marcela Guerrero and Drew Sawyer, take opposite approaches to the daunting if not impossible task of defining this exhibition. Guerrero speaks in theory, dangerously close to jargon, spending time on the phrase “gestational relationality”, to explain one of the ideas contained within the show. It doesn’t help. Sawyer’s more straightforward approach deals with the process of curating a show with such a broad and formless history. What does a Biennial seek to define? Is such a definition even possible in the fragmented archipelagoes of today’s art world?
What becomes clear, and is occasionally stated explicitly in the book, is how the concept of “American” is without a clear definition. Artists from Palestine, Afghanistan, Native American tribes, Hawaii, are simultaneously aware of their outsider status, yet they are inside as well – there is no question that they belong in an American art museum. Like art itself, identity is flexible and evolves continually. At times, even when the art did not excite me, the artist’s engagement with their ideas and work did. I enjoyed the book a lot more than I enjoyed the show itself.
I was distressed to see some artists speak positively about AI, but relieved that there were so few of them, and others had better ideas. Even the catalog’s low points have some value: Charles Ray and Isabelle Francis McGuire have an interesting conversation, but it has little to do with her work.
It wouldn’t be a review if I failed to quibble here and there. A little judicious editing might have helped, especially when the book is 500 pages long. Director Scott Rothkopf‘s introduction is really only four paragraphs long: after that he throws in a few paragraphs of standard museum boilerplate about the staff, and then some acknowledgements that should have gone into the Acknowledgments section that follows.
It would have been easy to create a dystopian Biennial to match the crumbling Empire around us, but Guerrero and Sawyer found moments of beauty and optimism even in these dark days. I found myself nodding and giving an emphatic “Yeah!” to artist Samia Halaby‘s quote below, which perfectly ends her conversation with Hannah Priscilla Craig, Director of Culture and Communication at the People’s Forum.

Text






























